The Fear of 13

The Fear of 13
James Earl Jones Theatre
May 26, 2026 

Photo courtesy of The Fear of 13

After being nominated for an Olivier Award for his London stage debut in The Fear of 13, Adrien Brody recreates his role in a stunning Broadway debut.  This is a compelling character in a gripping story of forgiveness and redemption.  Playwright Lindsey Ferrentino based this work on the documentary film by David Sington.  It is an evenly paced, well-structured play with high stakes and well-crafted dialogue.  Director David Cromer creates a tense and claustrophobic atmosphere, then widens the sense of despair.  As hope rises so does suspicion and doubt.  The tension returns, then releases, allowing for satisfying closure. 

Jacki Miles (played by Tessa Thompson) is an advocate for death row prisoners.  She visits once a week and listens, taking notes on the stories they tell and reporting on their treatment, health, and psychological needs.  One prisoner, Nick Yarris (played by Adrien Brody) gets her attention when he quotes from Catcher in the Rye.  Jacki researches the implausible stories he tells to confirm they are the truth.  She finds herself spending more time with him on her visits, and finally admits she is getting involved.  Nick declares to Jacki that he is innocent… and in love with her.  She insists he tell her the full story of how he became incarcerated before they address their emotional situation.  Jacki realizes she could have full access to Nick’s records to better assist with his appeal if they were married.  Once she makes this commitment, there is no turning back. 

Adrien Brody as Nick Yarris
Photo courtesy of The Fear of 13

Nick Yarris is an intense and fascinating character.  He is well read from his time on death row, so he is articulate and knows how weave incredible tales.  Adrien Brody projects a glib and beguiling façade as this character.  He renders child-like traits, while masking deep feelings of hurt and betrayal.  He is vulnerable and full of anguish.  As his darker side rises, you wonder how trustworthy he is.  The more Jacki believes him, the more you fear for her safety.  You want to believe him, but are never really sure.  It is this duality that draws you in emotionally.  

Adrien Brody & Tessa Thompson
Photo courtesy of The Fear of 13

Jacki Miles gradually opens up to Nick.  She takes her responsibilities as an advocate very seriously.  She develops a genuine tenderness for Nick over the course of her visits.  Since she does not jump in unknowingly, the audience willfully goes on this journey with her.  Tessa Thompson splendidly portrays this measured discovery and immersion of emotion.  Her character is sure of herself and confident in every step she takes.  Ms. Thompson and Mr. Brody skillfully shift in their susceptible moments, supporting one another as they waver between hope and helplessness.  Their connection is tender.  Their bond is visceral.

The Fear of 13 is playing at the James Earl Jones Theatre through July 12.  You must see these performances.  The characters go through a harrowing journey, making this play a unique and amazing experience. 

Domenick Danza