Two Strangers Carry a Cake Across New York

 Two Strangers Carry a Cake Across New York
Longacre Theatre
April 8, 2026 

Photo courtesy of
Two Stranger Carry a Cake Across New York

The Broadway production of Two Strangers Carry a Cake Across New York is funny, warm, and wonderful.  The book, music, and lyrics by Jim Barne and Kit Buchan are beautifully crafted.  The script is witty and charming, as two strangers from different parts of the world open up and get to know one another.  The lyrics give keen insight into their thoughts and desires, and the music is simply delightful.  Director Tim Jackson turns the two day journey of these characters into a life changing experience, for them as well as the audience. 

Robin (played by Christiani Pitts) is waiting at Kenndy Airport to pick up Dougal (played by understudy Austin Colburn), who is flying in from England.  They have never met.  Robin’s sister is marrying Dougal’s father.  Dougal unexpectedly received a wedding invitation.  He is very excited to meet his father for the first time and see the sights of New York.  Robin needs to get up early for work at a coffee shop and has no time for Dougal’s enthusiasm.  When he surprises her at work the next afternoon, she takes him with her on the train to Flatbush to pick up her sister’s wedding cake.  They get to know one another carrying the cake across New York, especially when they drop to top tier. 

Photo courtesy of Two Strangers Carry a Cake Across New York

The exuberance that Austin Colburn shows as Dougal is counterbalanced by Christiani Pitts’ portrayal of Robin’s native New York energy.  The script is full of constant banter between the characters.  Mr. Colburn and Ms. Pitts find the rhythm and timing that suits these scenes perfectly.  It’s light and funny, until the second act when they face their truths.  These moments are tense and genuine.  The plot turns as the characters take a realistic look at themselves, and the audience never knows where it will lead. 

Photo courtesy of Two Strangers Carry a Cake Across New York

Soutra Gilmour’s scenic design is made up of oversized stacks of luggage that transform into numerous locations throughout the story.  It is brilliantly conceived, as it carries the theme of journeying into every moment of the show.  The use of dual turntables keeps the action moving at a fascinating pace.

This new musical is a joyous experience.  It reminds us that life can change in a moment if we allow ourselves to take the journey. 

Two Strangers Carry a Cake Across New York is playing at the Longacre Theatre.  Get a ticket today! 

Domenick Danza