The Brothers Size

 The Brothers Size
The Shed
August 30, 2025

Photo courtesy of The Brothers Size

Tarell Alvin McCraney’s play, The Brothers Size, is a beautifully crafted piece of theatre.  In an interview (from the program), Mr. McCraney said, “The story is based on a Yoruba tale that I heard when I was younger.  It’s about the ways in which siblings exist in the world, and how we have to let go of who we are in order to be a better sibling.”  The storytelling style is crisp, rhythmic, and impactful.  The action is driven by raw emotion and urgent need.  Co-directors Bijan Sheibani and Tarell Alvin McCraney worked closely with choreographer Juel D. Lane to create a seamlessly stunning production.  The performances are flawless. 

Oshoosi Size (played by Alani iLongwe) has recently been released from prison.  His brother, Ogun (played by André Holland) pushes him to get motivated first thing in the morning.  When Oshoosi tells him he is presently in search of employment, Ogun immediately gives him a job at his mechanic shop.  He refuses to allow Oshoosi to say no, and even threatens to tell his parole officer if he turns down the work.  At the shop, Oshoosi meets up with Elegba (played by Malcolm Mays).  They previously knew one another, then bonded while serving their prison terms.  Ogun has a dream that Elegba is taking Oshoosi from him.  He tries to keep them apart.  When Elegba gives Oshoosi a car, their bond tightens.  Elegba’s motive becomes clear, but it is too late for Ogun to keep his brother safe. 

André Holland, Alani iLongwe, & Malcolm Mays
Photo courtesy of The Brothers Size 

André Holland and Alani iLongwe are brilliant together.  Their characters are strongly connected,
while being opposite in every way.  André Holland portrays Ogun as strict and structured.  Since their parents passed away, Ogun has always kept an eye on his younger brother, forcing him to be the responsible one.  Alani iLongwe’s Oshoosi is lighthearted and adventurous.  His older brother carries the weight of his always getting in trouble.  Mr. Holland emotionally and vividly expresses this burden, and Mr. iLongwe humorously portrays his character’s dependence and vulnerability.  You can’t help feeling their frustration, disappointment, and yearning.  They are amazingly in sync.  

Malcolm Mays brings a sense of danger to the character of Elegba, while also expressing his loneliness and susceptibility.  Oshoosi’s attraction to him is evident, as is Ogun’s mistrust.  Mr. Mays delivers a visceral portrayal that immediately establishes his character and invites the audience to discover his deeper longings, when he decides to reveal them. 

The Brothers Size is playing at The Shed through September 28.  It is a slick and unique production.  You need to experience it.     

Domenick Danza